Zoom Logo

Self-Funded Equity: Common & Preferred Structures for SBA - Shared screen with gallery view
Lisa Forrest
03:21
Please share your questions and comments in the chat and we'll get to them as we go along.
Theo Ciupitu
04:58
Will you circulate today’s presentyation to the attendees?
Heather Endresen
05:21
Yes, will will circulate the deck to all registrants
Lisa Forrest
05:23
Today's deck and recording will be shared with all the registrants later today
LaShawn James
09:54
You are recording.
Keelby Tiellery
11:42
Javier buen día
Braulio Nieves
16:29
Please go full screen
Nirav Shah
21:48
are searchers required to put their own funds along side equity investors? For SBA or conventional.
Heather Endresen
23:09
Nirav, this will vary from bank to bank. but often, the banks will want to see some funds from the searcher when using SBA debt. When using conventional debt, the searcher often does not contribute any equity $s
Tf
24:09
Would banks care about hybrid capital junior to the debt
Jesse Perron
24:26
Could the equity injection for an SBA loan be a 'gift' from the Seller?
Ruslan Sladkov
24:59
Are the investors then also subject to the PG if the breach the equity threshold of ~20% or is the JV structured in an alternative way?
Tanatsa Kamhunga
25:05
Or a "gift" from friends and family?
Heather Endresen
25:16
TF, if by hybrid capital you are referring to preferred equity, SBA lenders can allow this, but they don't allow mandatory distributions to investors.
Lisa Forrest
25:16
Equity injection cannot be in the form of gift from the seller.
Lisa Forrest
26:11
Injection can be from friends and family in the form of a gift....sba will allow that
Heather Endresen
26:26
SBA requires anyone with 20% or more "economic benefit" from the business (which includes preferred returns, if any) to provide a full PG. Often the investor equity is structured such that the investors are not required to PG
Tanatsa Kamhunga
26:56
What is the minimum required equity injection?
Lisa Forrest
27:09
If minority owners breach the 20% ownership/economic benefit, then the PG requirement will kick in
Jason Nguyen
27:22
What is Live Oak’s philosophy on full standby seller notes?
Lisa Forrest
27:27
SBA requires a minimum of 10% of the total project in equity
Jason Nguyen
27:50
Separately, is preferred equity with a PIK / cumulative dividends acceptable?
Anthony Clervi
29:00
Will this recording be sent out to all participants I assume?
Lisa Forrest
29:24
@Jason let's get to your question in a few more slides on Equity Metrics
Lisa Forrest
29:34
Recording will be sent to registrants
Heather Endresen
29:44
Jason, this can also vary bank to bank in terms of opinions on what is ok in a preferred equity structure and what is not. Basic rule of thumb is that when the preferred equity terms start to look too much like debt, the lenders will typically push back
Jason Nguyen
30:20
Thanks!
Lisa Forrest
30:50
Adding onto Heather's comment, we review the operating agreements
Theo Ciupitu
31:50
Can you use independent sponsor economics (e.g., preferred return and promote) in the self-funded, SBA context?
Heather Endresen
31:58
Jason, with regard to Standby Seller notes, we are comfortable with them depending on the circumstances. If you are talking about using a full standby seller note for 5% of the 10% equity - the best use cases for this are often highly technical businesses where buyer is a great fit and multiple is low because of the technical nature (as one example)
Ammon Lyle
32:29
When getting equity how are the funds stored? For example what vehicle/entity is the money stored in and how does the bank evaluate that?
Heather Endresen
33:03
Theo, using preferred equity can work, but using promote in an SBA funded deal is problematic because there are strict rules around any ownership changes that can be made while the SBA loan is outstanding.
Heather Endresen
34:03
Ammon, funds from equity investors typically stay in their accounts (which are verified with 60 days of bank statements prior to close) until they are wired in at close.
aj
34:53
When raising funds from investors - what requirements does the SBA lender have in terms of vetting the investor and what are they looking (ex requirement of investors to show bank statements, others?)
Ben Gottesman
35:02
Following up on that. If you’re only putting in 5% of the equity check, how do you end up with 75%+ of the common? How is that negotiated?
Ben Gottesman
35:56
Thanks
Heather Endresen
36:43
A, good question on vetting the investors. All SBA lenders require 60 days of bank statements prior to close. But if the investors are professional investors such as Ben or Cat, lenders may ask for a bio and list of deals they have previously invested in, and any experience with the particular industry, etc.
Lisa Forrest
36:44
Adding onto Heather's comment on the 5% standby...where we see this working best for balancing risks between lender, seller and buyer, if limiting equity to 5% of project, we'll also generally see additional seller note B to balance risk. it will be very situational and we'd love to talk about any projects you're interesting in discussing.
Brock Vandervliet
36:50
Regarding outside equity. why not pencil a potential return/IRR% an investor would demand. Say that's 20%. Then simply back into the equity % to drive that 20% return. Assumes tight proforma projections that the principal and investor agree on.
leigh lommen
37:53
What are you seeing these days in terms of LP rights? Pref rate. and Carry %
Heather Endresen
38:16
Brock, there are many ways to run models that can make sense, but ultimately the investor's confidence in your growth plans will be a big part of the equity raise
Lisa Forrest
38:54
@leigh we'll get to that Q in a few more slides
Heather Endresen
39:00
Leigh, equity terms vary widely. We'll touch on it here.
A
39:51
is there any other diligence that the bank will do outside of asking for 60 days of bank statements we should inform investors of in advance?
Lisa Forrest
39:56
@Brock we'll get to your observation in another couple of slides
Jay Subramaniam
40:17
Cat, thanks for your commentary?Is there any material on what diligence a bank performs on investors?
Lisa Forrest
40:27
@Ben we'll get to your question in another few slides
Ruslan Sladkov
41:13
Can the investors walk through an example transaction? (i.e., $1M EBITDA at 4x Multiple what does the structure look like equity vs debt and what does the searcher get it / have to put up)?
Daniel Angel
41:31
Can you talk through tax distributions - should they be included in IRR? What are the logistics of K-1s and ongoing distributions?
Heather Endresen
41:42
A - often the cap stack is being finalized very close to closing. A buyer can identify the who the lead investors are expected to be, what terms are expected, whether a board of directors will be put in place, and some background information on those investors and their prior experience in investing in SMBs
A
42:22
thanks
Jason Nguyen
42:49
@Eric I see a lot of questions about LP interest etc. do you typically see more opcos structured as c corps or partnership / LLCs?
Derek Sprunger
42:52
Can you comment on how long it can take (ballpark) for a $1M equity raise without friends and family?
Arun Sivaraman
43:30
With reference to personal guarantee's, how is one's personal holdings calculated should the assets be part of a trust?
Derek Sprunger
43:40
Can you comment on how long it can take (ballpark) for a $1M equity raise (through to investor commitment) without friends and family?
Daniel Angel
44:05
Thank you!
Ammon Lyle
45:06
Heather are they wiring the money to an LLC that will have cash on its books?
Ammon Lyle
45:29
And then the bank with wire money to that LLC as well?
Eric Pacifici
45:39
Replying to "@Eric I see a lot of..."I can address this.
Jason Nguyen
45:48
Thanks
Andrew Ponton
45:58
Do personal guarantees on SBA loans vary for each lender or is there a common baseline?
Heather Endresen
46:00
Ammon, where the funds get wired varies based on structure of the deal.
Mat Scholtec
46:48
Will this chat Q&A be available for reference after this call ends?
Lisa Forrest
47:03
Any individual owner that owns 20% + ownership has to personally gty. That's the SBA rule.
Adam Reed
47:11
Cat, can you share more details of what you
Heather Endresen
47:16
Andrew, SBA loan PG's do not vary generally. Banks follow the SBA guidelines strictly (PG required for all who own 20% of more economic benefit), but on occasion a lender may also require a PG for someone owning less than that if they believe it is needed
Ammon Lyle
47:18
@Heather Can you provide examples? I’m not sure how the the procedures of the acquisition actually take place
Adam Reed
47:46
Cat, can you share more of what you'd look for or expect in governance?
Heather Endresen
47:46
Ammon, let's do this after the call. The mechanics of funding are a bit in the weeds and vary based on structures.
Heather Endresen
48:00
The Q&A will be recorded as well, I believe
Arun Sivaraman
48:10
Replying to "Any individual owner..."Yes what does the personal guarantee mean if the searcher's personal funds/assets are in a trust. How does SBA/bank ascertain that the searcher has enough of a PG?
Mat Scholtec
48:18
Reacted to "The Q&A will be reco…" with 👍
Heather Endresen
49:11
Replying to "Any individual owner..."Varies from bank to bank. Some want to see specific amount of real estate or liquidity, others underwrite primarily to the business and not the PG individuals
Alberto Marquez
50:37
Sure someone has asked already and I missed it, but are the slides going to be available after call?
Luca Pizzuto
51:00
What type of deals generally use commercial debt vs SBA loans? Do equity investors generally focus on just one of the two or would they consider both depending on the deal?
Heather Endresen
51:06
Alberto, yes will be sending the slides to all registrants, and we will distribute a recorded of the session as well
Alberto Marquez
51:51
Thanks for this to all presenters and to you Lisa - truly!
Lisa Forrest
52:06
+1 to Heather on the strength of the PG. If you're working with a true cashflow lender, your lender is going to put a majority of the emphasis on the strength of the DSC and other aspects of the actual opportunity.
Heather Endresen
52:13
Luca, we see investor equity in both SBA funded and conventionally funded. NEarly all conventionally funded deals have investors, but only some SBA deals do.
Luca Pizzuto
52:45
Reacted to "Luca, we see investo..." with 👍
Ammon Lyle
53:22
@Heather I’m asking because I’m wondering if the bank is reviewing a shell company with cash as an asset and investors are buying shares in the company?
Ammon Lyle
53:31
But I appreciate you 👍
Tanatsa Kamhunga
54:05
That IRR is over what period ?
Brendan Snow
54:49
Question for panelists: Any thoughts on convertible preferred? Eg preferred that converts into common upon the passage of some key de-risking event or financial metric threshold. How un/common is this in deals you see? Thank you for your time!
Lisa Forrest
55:36
@Ammon let's talk in more detail after the call. And feel free to reach out to Ben or Cat or Eric directly as well
Ammon Lyle
56:50
Ok!
Jeff Sladick
57:27
Is there a standard investment period before exit to attain that IRR?
Joe Lattari
57:57
What tax distributions flow through to equity investors?
Daniel Angel
58:02
Should searchers contribution/investment be at the same terms as the preferred?
Matt Johnson
58:12
Is the typical expectation on preferred returns to be paid annually or only at liquidation event?
Jonathan McLaughlin
01:04:07
Is it correct to assume when you say investors who “understand small business investing” it’s because they understand the “punched in the face everyday” dynamics of SMB vs. simply being an accredited investors?
Heather Endresen
01:05:51
Jonathan, 🙂 THat is certainly part of their value. Other ways experienced SMB investors add value beyond the funding: another set of eyes during diligence, asking good questions, governance post-close, industry experience with other investments, access to their SMB network
JD Foote
01:06:07
Reacted to "Jonathan, 🙂 THat i..." with 👍🏻
JD Foote
01:06:43
Great points Lisa. GTG, thanks for putting this on! JD
Jim Helms
01:06:59
Don't they allow for professional experience to attain accredited investor status now?
Lisa Forrest
01:07:25
The transition from searcher to CEO is going to be different for every transaction and every situation is different so it's great having people in your corner that have done this before. Having investors working with you that have actually been operators provides incalculable value.
Theo Ciupitu
01:07:26
Can you use 506(b) if you only do email outreach?
Ali Evans
01:09:15
THANK YOU! VERY VERY Helpful session
Jacob Hall
01:09:27
@Jim if you hold a Series 7, 65 or 82 license you are granted accredited status-not legal advice :-)
Braulio Nieves
01:10:14
But what about if I just put equity alongside 3 more partners. We are going to be partners. Do I still have to go thru that Reg D structure?
Ray Bustami
01:11:42
Does a searcher's salary for the past year or two play a big part in the underwriting process?
Chris Sarkesian
01:11:44
How are you typically seeing senior management compensated in terms of equity (if at all)?
Brendan Snow
01:12:03
Thank you Catherine and Ben for your answers!
Alex Medearis
01:12:21
As an investor, how do you think about the potential for further financing in the case that the business goes through a rough patch or wants to do other acquisitions? Do you look for protections against future dilution?
Lisa Forrest
01:13:16
@ RAY we understand that you've likely been searching for the past year if you're doing this full-time and we might not expect to see income on your PTR
Lisa Forrest
01:14:35
For those specific legal questions we didn't get to, I would recommend reaching out to Eric directly and also discussing with your own counsel
Kevin Laleyan
01:14:40
Have you seen a forced buyout clause where equity investors can be bought out at a pre-negotiated rate of return at term or upon achievement of some kind of milestone?
Eric Pacifici
01:14:48
Reacted to "For those specific l..." with 👍
leigh lommen
01:15:21
Have you done roll-ups as a SF investment?
JAVIER ARMANDO GOMEZ BARCENA
01:15:24
thank you very much for the session!
Kevin Laleyan
01:16:40
Part of the buyer plan that was mentioned before relies on the assumption that an owner-operator can clearly predict growth over 5-7 years. What if strategy was to exit in 5 years but that changes over time where owner/operator chooses to keep the business forever?
Brooks Bergreen
01:17:24
How is IRR calculated.. is it annual or is it at exit?
Arun Sivaraman
01:19:21
Panel opinion on whether searcher can be kicked out for anything other than fraud?
Brendan Snow
01:19:31
I have to step away but this was wonderful. Thanks very much to all the panelists and participants for the great questions!
Heather Endresen
01:19:42
Reacted to "I have to step away ..." with 👍
Peyton Vitter
01:22:09
@lisa What’s your formula for lease adjusted leverage ratio?
Kevin Laleyan
01:22:14
Great answers based on experience, thank you!
Jacob Hall
01:23:47
Thank you all!
Antonios Hadjigeorgalis
01:23:49
Thank you. Great presentation!
David Lovejoy
01:23:53
Thank you Cat, Ben, Eric, Lisa, and Heather for sharing your time and expertise—and thank you to everyone else for the great questions!
Arun Sivaraman
01:24:03
👏🏾
Gregory Couvreur
01:24:03
thank you all!
James McAlpine
01:24:04
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and insights!
Cody Agee
01:24:09
Appreciate the time!
Ben Gottesman
01:24:14
Awesome guys - thanks for this
Nathaniel Garvey
01:24:18
Thank you!
Alberto Marquez
01:24:23
This was fantastic - thanks again!!!!!
Luca Pizzuto
01:24:25
Thanks to Lisa and all the panelist - terrific session!
David Eng
01:24:26
Super informative, thanks everyone!
Alex Medearis
01:24:28
Great discussion, thanks!